The Genius Within Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing Dr Frank T Vertosick Jr 9780156027311 Books
Download As PDF : The Genius Within Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing Dr Frank T Vertosick Jr 9780156027311 Books
Can bacteria be as smart as we are? Can ants think? And fish? Yes, says Frank Vertosick, a neurosurgeon who combats our elitism about intelligence in this brilliant book.
A gifted writer and author of the widely praised Why We Hurt, Vertosick shows us that intelligence--the ability to react to the outside world, to change behavior, and survive-can be found wherever life exists. He demonstrates the keen intelligence of our immune system, how lowly bacteria mutate and outwit antibiotics, and how canny cancer cells elude our natural defenses.
A fascinating journey through worlds of unknown science and an unsettling argument against our valuing of brain intelligence above all else, The Genius Within tells a fascinating scientific story, one that could shake our ethical foundation to its core.
that the author makes in not being technical is only partically
true. First, he concentrates too much on the medical explanations
that, at times, are not entirely relevant. Second, his analogies
are silly at times particularly when the concept is
already well understood without the analogy. One has to know
that the number of analogies given is not directly proportional
to how clear the concept will become to the reader.
But as I said, this is a good book and if you can live by
the parts of the book that are irrelevant you may learn
something new about the concept of intelligence and how
intelligence can be observed in seemingly "dumb" things.
Tags : Buy The Genius Within: Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing on Amazon.com ✓ FREE SHIPPING on qualified orders,Dr. Frank T. Vertosick Jr.,The Genius Within: Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing,Mariner Books,0156027313,Science Life Sciences Evolution
People also read other books :
If you want to know why Darwin might be "needlessy nihilistic" and what is at the core of Vertosick's carefully built case to explain--nothing less than--the possisble meaning of everything, then check this out. I thought the beginning was a little tedious, but the pay-off for hanging in there with his carefully crafted case was well worth it. I've bought several copies to share with friends and have had many lively debates. Thanks Dr. Vertosick for your emergent property--it's marvelous!
As easy to read as a novel and just as enjoyable, it will forever change the way you see the world around you. It is one of those rare books that links together a number of more or less well known ideas and arrives at an extraordinary and inescapable set of conclusions. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
I didn't buy the author's claim that the biological systems he discusses qualify as human-equivalent or human-superior intelligences. The problem is that the author's model of intelligence doesn't come close to encompassing all of the mental operations we humans use to solve problems. Nevertheless, I found the book to be an enjoyable thought experiment. I would like to see a 2nd edition featuring a more sophisticated model of cognition.
"The Genius Within" is a must read for the non-specialist interested in science. It is a thought provoking work; very speculative, but grounded in mainstream scientific fact and theory. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it...twice. It's a bit technical at times, so some familiarity with the science involved is recommended. Also, if you happen to be more interested in "intelligent" animal behavior as such, rather than in its biochemical, microbiological and systemic underpinnings, you may want to look elsewhere.
In this book, the author explores the notion the "networks" underlie the phenomenon we call life, and that life is synonymous with the information processing - intelligence - they architect. We tend to think of intelligence as a unique feature of brains, our conscious ones in particular (he calls this "brain chauvinism"), but he contends that all life is intelligent, or at least as "intelligent as it needs to be", and sets out to prove it.
In simplest terms, he defines intelligence as the ability to solve problems related to survival. This seems to run counter to mainstream evolutionary theory, where the survival of species is basically as matter of, well, "dumb luck". But the author views intelligence as a collective phenomenon firmly embedded within this framework; as an "emergent behavior" of large groups of highly interactive biological entities (Including sub-cellular enzymes) otherwise engaged in a contingency-driven, random struggle for survival. The architecture that endows such groups with "emergent properties" is called, for want of a better word, a "network" by the author.
The details of what the author means by a "network" is closely argued and beyond the scope of this review. In general, a biological "network" is a large collection of "selfish", randomly interacting entities whose components are capable of two or more relatively stable, but reversible, states (more active/less active, faster/slower, stronger/weaker), and whose components can variously enhance or impede each other's status over time, resulting in a collective "energy landscape" patterned by forces impinging on the network. The former allows for basic information storage (the biological equivalent of zeros and ones), and the latter for collective information storage (pattern recognition/memory) concerning the environment, allowing the collective to respond to environmental stimuli in, ultimately, a manner conducive to its survival. Overall, the architecture of a "network" harnesses the random, contingent interactions of its constituents into the directed or, as the author would claim, intelligent actions we associate with life at every level of biological organization.
The author spends much of the book "fleshing out" these and other abstractions, particularly with respects to interacting aggregates composed of things such as cellular enzymes, bacteria and somatic cells, what he calls "party networks" as opposed to "hard wired networks", though he does give ample attention to the latter (he is, after all, a brain surgeon). To assess intelligence from the "outside in", he employs a modified version of the Touring Test throughout these forays. Without making any assumptions about them based on what they are or how they're organized, he queries each system with a problem, and waits for a response. He queries an infectious bacterial species with a new antibiotic and, within months, it develops immunity. He queries the human immune system with the aforementioned bacteria and, within weeks, it develops an effective resistance. In these and other instances, he argues for an "intelligent" response from each based on their participation in network architecture, no more or less effective for the overall survival of its hosts than the quickened responses of "hard wired" brains.
I gave this book a five-star rating, and with good reason, but I'm not entirely in agreement with its conclusions. Although "networking" is arguably a characteristic of all living systems, it seems somewhat disingenuous to define intelligence as the ability to solve problems regardless of the time frame involved. Given enough time and numbers, "dumb luck" will achieve results that appear intelligent, and so will tempt teleological interpretations. Mainstream evolutionists have long had to contend with our compulsion to put a "forger" between the hammers of chance and the anvil of necessity. Like them, I suspect the author's hypothesis, however plausible, is just another in a series of attempts to inject Vitalism into biology, "networks" here replacing the less than scientific musings of an earlier age.
But then again, maybe I'm just a "brain chauvinist".
Vertosick puts forth a point of view that we need to start thinking a bit more open-mindedly about what intelligence is. He gives very convicing examples of how things like the immune system, bacterial colonies, even cancer cells are intelligent. And relates them all to a Big Concept Networks. He proposes that not just brains, but all types of intelligent systems are networks with emergent properties from lots of interactions and from Darwinian processes. I feel as I read it that he has taken a number of ill-formed, fuzzy Ideas that I have been thinking about, and made them clear and tangible. He is a great writer, who uses a lot of analogies to help us through the sometimes very technical material. It is one of those books that every thinking person must read, and I promise it will change you.
In my opinion, this is an important but complex book. Vertosick presents ideas based upon a sound, but I think, poorly referenced scientific basis. He explores how basins of attraction help us understand all levels of biology, from chemical / cellular reactions to the immune system to the brain. His basic model is that large collections of relatively simple parts can act in a network based upon Darwinian selection principles. For example, chemical reactions, directed by enzymes, are driven to find their most energy efficient solutions. The most successful reactions will dominate the rest. Vertosick details how his ideas apply to the cell, to the immune system and to the brain. I have read a lot of the groundwork material and so was prepared for concepts like basins of attraction, the general reader could have used a better notes or reference section.
I did not like the way any of the story lines.
This is a relatively good book to read. However, the promise
that the author makes in not being technical is only partically
true. First, he concentrates too much on the medical explanations
that, at times, are not entirely relevant. Second, his analogies
are silly at times particularly when the concept is
already well understood without the analogy. One has to know
that the number of analogies given is not directly proportional
to how clear the concept will become to the reader.
But as I said, this is a good book and if you can live by
the parts of the book that are irrelevant you may learn
something new about the concept of intelligence and how
intelligence can be observed in seemingly "dumb" things.
A gifted writer and author of the widely praised Why We Hurt, Vertosick shows us that intelligence--the ability to react to the outside world, to change behavior, and survive-can be found wherever life exists. He demonstrates the keen intelligence of our immune system, how lowly bacteria mutate and outwit antibiotics, and how canny cancer cells elude our natural defenses.
A fascinating journey through worlds of unknown science and an unsettling argument against our valuing of brain intelligence above all else, The Genius Within tells a fascinating scientific story, one that could shake our ethical foundation to its core.
The Genius Within Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing Dr Frank T Vertosick Jr 9780156027311 Books
This is a relatively good book to read. However, the promisethat the author makes in not being technical is only partically
true. First, he concentrates too much on the medical explanations
that, at times, are not entirely relevant. Second, his analogies
are silly at times particularly when the concept is
already well understood without the analogy. One has to know
that the number of analogies given is not directly proportional
to how clear the concept will become to the reader.
But as I said, this is a good book and if you can live by
the parts of the book that are irrelevant you may learn
something new about the concept of intelligence and how
intelligence can be observed in seemingly "dumb" things.
Product details
|
Tags : Buy The Genius Within: Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing on Amazon.com ✓ FREE SHIPPING on qualified orders,Dr. Frank T. Vertosick Jr.,The Genius Within: Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing,Mariner Books,0156027313,Science Life Sciences Evolution
People also read other books :
- Ellie Crows Admirable Women Volume 2 MaryAnn Myers 9780966878059 Books
- Rage of the Old Gods The Books of the World Spectrum Book 1 eBook Tyler FM Edwards
- Mendelssohn Variations sérieuses Op 54 FELIX MENDELSSOHN BARTHOLDY MICHAEL KUBE 0800522002670 Books
- FRESH NEW LOOK Crossdressing Feminization Transformation edition by Nikki Crescent Literature Fiction eBooks
- Fucking Mermaid edition by Lilith Grimm Literature Fiction eBooks
The Genius Within Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing Dr Frank T Vertosick Jr 9780156027311 Books Reviews
If you want to know why Darwin might be "needlessy nihilistic" and what is at the core of Vertosick's carefully built case to explain--nothing less than--the possisble meaning of everything, then check this out. I thought the beginning was a little tedious, but the pay-off for hanging in there with his carefully crafted case was well worth it. I've bought several copies to share with friends and have had many lively debates. Thanks Dr. Vertosick for your emergent property--it's marvelous!
As easy to read as a novel and just as enjoyable, it will forever change the way you see the world around you. It is one of those rare books that links together a number of more or less well known ideas and arrives at an extraordinary and inescapable set of conclusions. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
I didn't buy the author's claim that the biological systems he discusses qualify as human-equivalent or human-superior intelligences. The problem is that the author's model of intelligence doesn't come close to encompassing all of the mental operations we humans use to solve problems. Nevertheless, I found the book to be an enjoyable thought experiment. I would like to see a 2nd edition featuring a more sophisticated model of cognition.
"The Genius Within" is a must read for the non-specialist interested in science. It is a thought provoking work; very speculative, but grounded in mainstream scientific fact and theory. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it...twice. It's a bit technical at times, so some familiarity with the science involved is recommended. Also, if you happen to be more interested in "intelligent" animal behavior as such, rather than in its biochemical, microbiological and systemic underpinnings, you may want to look elsewhere.
In this book, the author explores the notion the "networks" underlie the phenomenon we call life, and that life is synonymous with the information processing - intelligence - they architect. We tend to think of intelligence as a unique feature of brains, our conscious ones in particular (he calls this "brain chauvinism"), but he contends that all life is intelligent, or at least as "intelligent as it needs to be", and sets out to prove it.
In simplest terms, he defines intelligence as the ability to solve problems related to survival. This seems to run counter to mainstream evolutionary theory, where the survival of species is basically as matter of, well, "dumb luck". But the author views intelligence as a collective phenomenon firmly embedded within this framework; as an "emergent behavior" of large groups of highly interactive biological entities (Including sub-cellular enzymes) otherwise engaged in a contingency-driven, random struggle for survival. The architecture that endows such groups with "emergent properties" is called, for want of a better word, a "network" by the author.
The details of what the author means by a "network" is closely argued and beyond the scope of this review. In general, a biological "network" is a large collection of "selfish", randomly interacting entities whose components are capable of two or more relatively stable, but reversible, states (more active/less active, faster/slower, stronger/weaker), and whose components can variously enhance or impede each other's status over time, resulting in a collective "energy landscape" patterned by forces impinging on the network. The former allows for basic information storage (the biological equivalent of zeros and ones), and the latter for collective information storage (pattern recognition/memory) concerning the environment, allowing the collective to respond to environmental stimuli in, ultimately, a manner conducive to its survival. Overall, the architecture of a "network" harnesses the random, contingent interactions of its constituents into the directed or, as the author would claim, intelligent actions we associate with life at every level of biological organization.
The author spends much of the book "fleshing out" these and other abstractions, particularly with respects to interacting aggregates composed of things such as cellular enzymes, bacteria and somatic cells, what he calls "party networks" as opposed to "hard wired networks", though he does give ample attention to the latter (he is, after all, a brain surgeon). To assess intelligence from the "outside in", he employs a modified version of the Touring Test throughout these forays. Without making any assumptions about them based on what they are or how they're organized, he queries each system with a problem, and waits for a response. He queries an infectious bacterial species with a new antibiotic and, within months, it develops immunity. He queries the human immune system with the aforementioned bacteria and, within weeks, it develops an effective resistance. In these and other instances, he argues for an "intelligent" response from each based on their participation in network architecture, no more or less effective for the overall survival of its hosts than the quickened responses of "hard wired" brains.
I gave this book a five-star rating, and with good reason, but I'm not entirely in agreement with its conclusions. Although "networking" is arguably a characteristic of all living systems, it seems somewhat disingenuous to define intelligence as the ability to solve problems regardless of the time frame involved. Given enough time and numbers, "dumb luck" will achieve results that appear intelligent, and so will tempt teleological interpretations. Mainstream evolutionists have long had to contend with our compulsion to put a "forger" between the hammers of chance and the anvil of necessity. Like them, I suspect the author's hypothesis, however plausible, is just another in a series of attempts to inject Vitalism into biology, "networks" here replacing the less than scientific musings of an earlier age.
But then again, maybe I'm just a "brain chauvinist".
Vertosick puts forth a point of view that we need to start thinking a bit more open-mindedly about what intelligence is. He gives very convicing examples of how things like the immune system, bacterial colonies, even cancer cells are intelligent. And relates them all to a Big Concept Networks. He proposes that not just brains, but all types of intelligent systems are networks with emergent properties from lots of interactions and from Darwinian processes. I feel as I read it that he has taken a number of ill-formed, fuzzy Ideas that I have been thinking about, and made them clear and tangible. He is a great writer, who uses a lot of analogies to help us through the sometimes very technical material. It is one of those books that every thinking person must read, and I promise it will change you.
In my opinion, this is an important but complex book. Vertosick presents ideas based upon a sound, but I think, poorly referenced scientific basis. He explores how basins of attraction help us understand all levels of biology, from chemical / cellular reactions to the immune system to the brain. His basic model is that large collections of relatively simple parts can act in a network based upon Darwinian selection principles. For example, chemical reactions, directed by enzymes, are driven to find their most energy efficient solutions. The most successful reactions will dominate the rest. Vertosick details how his ideas apply to the cell, to the immune system and to the brain. I have read a lot of the groundwork material and so was prepared for concepts like basins of attraction, the general reader could have used a better notes or reference section.
I did not like the way any of the story lines.
This is a relatively good book to read. However, the promise
that the author makes in not being technical is only partically
true. First, he concentrates too much on the medical explanations
that, at times, are not entirely relevant. Second, his analogies
are silly at times particularly when the concept is
already well understood without the analogy. One has to know
that the number of analogies given is not directly proportional
to how clear the concept will become to the reader.
But as I said, this is a good book and if you can live by
the parts of the book that are irrelevant you may learn
something new about the concept of intelligence and how
intelligence can be observed in seemingly "dumb" things.
0 Response to "⇒ Download Free The Genius Within Discovering the Intelligence of Every Living Thing Dr Frank T Vertosick Jr 9780156027311 Books"
Post a Comment